1 In Modest Closet

A Modest Girl’s Shoes

“You can totally look nice in your skirts and dresses without looking “frumpy” or “grandma-ish”, while still being simple, modest and even mindful of your health with the right kind of shoes! “

Hi Everyone!

I pray you are doing well! I recently had to do a little shoe shopping and I felt impressed to do this blog post because the following thoughts starting coming back to my mind. (Note: this post is being reposted some years after the original post! ;))

As I was growing closer to the Lord a couple of years ago, my dress changed because my heart had changed.  When the light of Christ comes in our hearts and we come to know the beauty of His holiness, we can’t stay exactly the same as before.  He causes us to be “born again” new creatures – our thoughts, likes, actions, etc. change! But it didn’t stop with skinny jeans and lower cut tops.  I realized that even the shoes I wore would tell if I was seeking to bring glory and honor to God by being simple, neat and serving their purpose, or  if I was seeking to glorify myself and to foster my pride by being flashy and drawing attention to me, my feet and my legs. With  those convictions I ended up getting rid of many pairs of shoes, leading to this recent shoe shopping because…*drumroll*… I no longer wear high heels

Why? Well to sum it up, to glorify God because I love Him!  But more specifically there were two main reasons that I’ll explain below.  I will also share with you types of shoes that go nicely with long skirts and dresses so continue to read on for those ideas! I pray that they will be a blessing 🙂 (Please note that I am not judging or condemning those who do or believe differently. I am just sharing the conviction the Lord placed on my heart as I have been praying, studying and striving to let Him work on my heart and change me so that I can be a true modest and virtuous daughter of God, within and without, to rightly represent His character in this dying world! :-)) 

Why I Stopped Wearing Heels

#1) The influence of the outward appearance for self vs. for God.


The additional height and instep of heels cause women to have to walk a certain way that actually draws attention to them.  Do you know what I mean? They cause women to have to sway their hips a little more because they are taking either quick, forceful and short strides, or long strides to trying to maintain their balance — otherwise they look awkward if they don’t know how to “walk in them right”.  Think about how the fashion models have to walk in their heels — long strides, or short and forceful ones all along with swinging hips.  There are so many websites and videos you can watch online now to teach you how to walk in heels.  One sight even said this ” Catwalk models will often cross one foot slightly in front of the other to give their hips a little more sway, but it’ll take some extra practice to master this.[1]And think about it – should we have to spend time training to walk in shoes (when we aren’t babies)? Let us rather train to walk in Christ’s shoes 🙂  Many will advise young women to spend a day wearing there new high heels in the house to get used to walking in them, while so many aren’t even privileged to own one pair of practical, comfortable, everyday shoes at all!  So much of God’s precious time is wasted to glorify self.  Will we be good stewards of the Lord’s time and money? 
When taking a look from the outside, I noticed that my fellow sisters, when wearing high heels, had to walk in a way, whether they realized it or not, that was actually seductive to our brothers in Christ (swinging hips and rear and magnified attention to the legs).  Now they were simply walking in such a way so that they could keep their balance, but many didn’t even realize, just like when I wore them, how it could cause their brothers to stumble.


  High heels, especially now, are made to draw so much attention.  I mean, I know from experience!  When I had a nice pair of high heels, I loved how my legs looked with them on, and my friends would always compliment my shoes! “Those are soooo cute!” Some dared to even say “Those are so ‘sexy’ ” (insinuating just what type of mindset wearing or seeing someone in high heels usually stimulates). “How do you walk in those?!” “Ooo, where did you get those from?!”.  These comments still echo in memory’s hall.

But shouldn’t  my character and dress have been drawing my friends to the beautiful simplicity and humility of Christ  and not to praise some high,unnatural, and uncomfortable, while yet somehow ‘cute’ contraption on my foot? (LOL, I had to say it – heels are like torture machines! So unnatural! Hehe, LOL). It was like when I went to church, everyone became so wrapped up in the outfits and shoes we all had on – it truly became like a fashion show.

So to sum up reason one I wanted to honor God by being humble and simple in how I dressed myself so that attention wasn’t brought to me and my clothes, but to the beauty of Christ. I didn’t want to be a distraction to my brothers in Christ by the way I would have to walk in high heels, and I didn’t want to distract my sisters either by feeding a love for mere display and worldly fashion.

“Whose adorning let it not be that outward adorning of plaiting the hair, and of wearing of gold, or of putting on of apparel; But let it be the hidden man of the heart, in that which is not corruptible, even the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price.” -1 Peter 3:3,4 

#2) My body isn’t my own.   

God holds me accountable to care for my, nay – His  temple, physically, so that I can better commune with Him, and so His Holy Spirit can better dwell in me, spiritually.  Did you know that wearing heels causes damage to your body and isn’t good for your health?  Multiple studies have proven that wearing heels negatively affects your muscles, tendons, bones, back and posture.  Click here for a list of some articles about the topic!

For me, I like to stick with simple, nice flat shoes so that I don’t have to ever worry about health issues, balancing and not falling, bad posture, getting a heel caught in a crack, etc. This way, more of my mind can focus on Christ and less about what is on my feet. Flat shoes are more natural and simple, while still being able to be nice and appealing… as Jesus is 😉  Simple, nice flats can still be beautiful but are more “humble” and “modest” I guess one could say!

You know, it’s amazing how we can do things that are painful and that we know are harmful to ourselves, just to glorify and gratify ourselves and even others!  Whether it is the food we eat, how we treat others or what we wear – we can know it isn’t good for us mentally, physically or spiritually, but when self is in the way (meaning Christ isn’t in the picture), we make some pretty interesting decisions that I am sure make the angels look in awe. “Beauty is pain” is the saying pushed on young women to encourage them to keep on trying to wear these fashion statements regardless of even physical pain. We are being trained by society to be “slaves to fashion!” I wonder how Jesus feels when He sees this happening all over the world — training little girls to do anything to look nice 🙁



   Now, after not having worn heels for so long,  if I even try on a pair of low heels or wedges, my feet and calves start to hurt! This is because of the physical effects on our feet and calf muscles and tendons. They shorten/shrink and tense up when we wear heels, and then when we wear flats, they have to stretch back out and that ends up being painful after wearing heels over a period of time! The muscles in your calves can even weaken and shorten permanently! Isn’t that crazy? No to mention calluses and bunions/corns! I used to wear 3+ inch shoes and now I can’t even wear 1 1/2 inch heels…it’s amazing how our body responds! I transitioned from heels to wedges and little by little the Holy Spirit kept impressing me with these thoughts (actually against my own desire to wear heels and wedges because I thought they were so “cute”) until my desire became new and completely different from what it was before.  It’s amazing how God changes us!  If you want more info about how heels affect your health, there are some really cool and informative pictures and a link at the very bottom of this blog!  Check it out 🙂

“What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own? For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God’s.”  -1 Corinthians 6:19, 20-

So…What to Wear?

So now you can kind of see why I made the decision to get rid of my heels — but now what do I wear? I went shopping recently and found some really nice flats and sandals that would go great with my skirts and dresses this Spring and Summer for not only casual attire,  but for work, church and more formal occasions!  I hope these ideas can help you.  If you would like to see how to pair these shoes with skirts and dresses, please let me know! I would love to make a video on it if it can help you 🙂  You can totally look nice in your skirts and dresses without looking “frumpy” or “grandma-ish”, while still being simple, modest and even mindful of your health with the right kind of shoes!  

All we do should be to please God because we love Him – salvation is a gift and we show we are thankful for that gift by giving God all the glory due to Him.  It is only God that works in us to do good (Philippians 2:13) – let us let Him live His life within us!  

Oh, and please consider this

There is a quote from a website about how to wear heels that says this:Wearing high heels can make you stand so that your legs look slimmer, your stomach flatter, and your femininity unstoppable.  It can also do wonders for your stride, but walking in high heels is not a natural talent – it’s a learned skill by practice and discipline.” 

But I challenge you to consider this thought and to live it, by God’s grace, in your lives:

“Having the character of Christ makes you stand strong so that when others see you, you look and are happier; you look and are more loving; and makes your desire to live for Him by loving and serving others, obeying Him and being a virtuous woman, unstoppable.  It can also do wonders for your faith, but having the character of Christ is not natural to our carnal minds and nature – it is a learned lifestyle made by beholding and following our dear and loving Saviour by letting Him change our hearts by His grace, and made also by practice, discipline and conquering  self.” 

Modest Shoes

(Note: I didn’t include sandals in this list, because I think most of us know that sandals are awesome with skirts and dresses! So don’t leave those out ;-))

Flats (Ballet Style):

I would like to say that flats are a modest girl’s “best friends”. There are so many styles of flats and they go perfectly with skirts and dresses! They can be casual or formal and worn in the hot weather and even in the colder weather with some tights! Flats are perfect for everyday use and especially for occasions when sandals/flip flops may not be appropriate (such as work or church).  Flats are totally comfy, cute, modest, simple and very becoming for a young lady growing up in Christ. Below are some types of pairs that I  personally have and that I’ve been using for even years and years!

Casual Example: These are neutral flats that I generally wear for everyday use – casual AND formal! I got this pair from DSW (brand: Steve Madden), and I actually am on my 2nd pair! They are that great LOL.

Formal Example: I tend to go for a more “pointy” flat for church and more formal occasions — they just seem a bit more nice and formal to me I guess! Black is a great basic color shoe that can go with just about everything! I got this pair from DSW and have been wearing them for YEARS! Brand: Steve Madden




Boots are so practical, versatile and also go very nicely with longer skirts and dresses!  During the cold and harsh months of the year, knee high boots keep my feet and legs extra warm and protected from the harsh elements,  look very nice with skirts and dresses, go with everything I wear, and are very comfortable. I recommend having a knee high length pair of boots first before having an ankle high or mid-calf height pair, because if you end up wearing a skirt or dress that isn’t down to your ankles, some lower boot height and shorter skirt combos might be a little awkward ! But that’s just an idea/personal preference! 🙂  Here are examples of the boots  I’ve been wearing and loving!


Brown is a neutral color that goes with pretty much everything like black does! It’s great to be able to wear these with almost everything — especially those outfits that have more brown involved. A great plus is that you can alternate between these and the black pair throughout the fall and winter so you won’t wear out one as quickly! With just these two, you’re pretty much set! Neutral goes far! 🙂 The tall brown pair I now have are from Khols and are the brand “Croft & Barrow”. They were on a great sale too!


In the Fall and Winter, I wear black boots all the time! My dad always taught me that investing in a good pair of boots is wise because you will always wear them, so if you invest in a good quality pair, it will save you money in the long run! I also like the kind of boots that I can wear both casually and to church as needed :-). Some places to find some good quality and not too expensive boots are department stores like JC Penny, Kohl’s & Macy’s, stores like Target, and common shoe stores like DSW, Shoe Department & Payless.! The one tall pair I have now are from JC Penny and the brand “Nine West” if you’re interested in finding the same/or a similar pair.







Sneakers, Boat Shoes, Moccasins, Espadrilles

We all need a decent pair of comfy shoes/sneakers for those super comfy days when you may be doing a lot of walking, running errands, light exercising, etc.  Below are types of sneakers and more comfy flats that I find go well with skirts.  I know that is a concern with many girls when they decide to dress modestly in longer skirts and dresses. It seems sometimes that the only option is to look “grandma-ish” or “frumpy”, but don’t fear. The Lord always offers “something better” – these styles of sneakers work great for me and my skirts!  Moccasins are another great comfy and casual shoe option that looks great with skirts and dresses! If you’d like a blog post on how I wear sneakers with skirts (especially for my younger modest girls), please let me know!

LOW TOP SNEAKERS like these go so nicely with maxi and midi length skirts! I love these! The fact that they are a neutral color means that they go with so much too 🙂 Similar shoes are low top converse all-stars, TOMS & BOBS. (Pictured: Lauren Ralph Lauren Jolie Round Toe Suede Oxford )

Another LOW TOP sneaker! Black BOBS (sooo comfy with the memory foam and great for canvassing/literature evangelism! That’s actually why I got these 😉 )


Moccasins are soooo comfy, and are especially nice with some tights for the Fall time when it’s cooler but not so cold that you need boots!

ESPADRILLES are another versatile and comfy option that go well with skirts and dresses of all lengths! Now, you may have to have a certain taste to like these, but I personally love them :). They’re great for when you still want to be dressed a bit more polished like a lady, but also want to be super comfy while you are out and about! I have a pair similar to these!










Styling Ideas

Bonus Info:
Heels & Your Health!

These pictures and more detailed info can be found here!

You Might Also Like

1 Comment

  • Reply
    6 Simplest Ways to Find Affordable Shoes For Women – alivia's blog
    July 27, 2018 at 11:20 am

    […] When looking for shoes items on the web, you should be particular or correct. For instance, to scan for shoes for women, you should you the citation sign along these lines “Modest Shoes For Women”.  […]

  • Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.